In our initial exploration in February 2021, we delved into the intricacies surrounding the “Rolex Batgirl” moniker attributed to the GMT-Master II reference 126710BLNR. In light of Rolex’s recent update offering the model with both Oyster and Jubilee bracelets, the question arises: Should there be distinct nicknames for the black and blue Rolex GMT-Master II, or is it time to unify them under the “Rolex Batman” umbrella? 
Upon discontinuing the first Batman GMT reference 116710BLNR in 2019 and introducing the revamped reference 126710BLNR, the primary distinction lay in the Jubilee bracelet replacing the Oyster bracelet. However, with the current model offering both bracelet options, the validity of the “Batgirl” nickname comes into question.
Streamlining Nicknames: The Case for Rolex Batman
Examining Rolex GMT-Master II nicknames reveals a precedent of simplicity based on bezel color. For instance, all red and blue insert-equipped GMT replica watches bear the “Pepsi” moniker, irrespective of model specifics. Applying this logic, consolidating all black and blue GMT-Master II models under the “Rolex Batman” nickname seems plausible. The recent availability of both bracelets further supports this streamlined nomenclature.
Moreover, consistency with other Rolex collections, such as the universally recognized “Rolex President” for the Day-Date series, highlights the practicality of singular, widely accepted nicknames.
Embracing Diversity: The Case for Rolex Batgirl
In the realm of Rolex, unofficial nicknames often cater to specific models or configurations. The “Smurf” exclusively refers to the 18k white gold Submariner ref. 116619LB, exemplifying the uniqueness of certain designations. Retaining the “Batgirl” label acknowledges the spontaneity and diversity inherent in Rolex nicknames, providing clarity within the collecting community.
Shorthand clarity, especially for communication within the Rolex enthusiast sphere, favors the continued use of “Rolex Batgirl” as it distinctly identifies the model equipped with a Jubilee bracelet.
Insights from the Community
To gain a broader perspective, industry enthusiasts shared their opinions on the Rolex Batman vs. Batgirl debate:
Rob (@spanishrob)
Preferring the Oyster bracelet for the Batman, Rob acknowledges the charm of the Batgirl nickname and its community-driven origin.
Eli (@watchesofgibraltar)
Emphasizing comfort, Eli favors the Batgirl on the Jubilee bracelet, finding its dynamic appearance and refined blue shade appealing.
Sam (@samray_gtr)
Sam sees the Batgirl nickname as a conversation starter, potentially appealing to a broader audience and appreciates the dynamic aesthetics of the Jubilee version.
Ripley (@ripley.sellers)
Critical of the Batgirl nickname’s divergence from established GMT-Master naming conventions, Ripley suggests alternative names for the Oyster bracelet version.
Justin (@abeautifulwrist)
Arguing for the unification of nicknames under Rolex Batman, Justin acknowledges the Jubilee’s refinement while expressing a preference for the Oyster bracelet.
The ongoing debate surrounding replica Rolex Batman vs. Rolex Batgirl reflects the dynamic nature of the collecting community. Whether to consolidate under a singular nickname or celebrate diversity, the discussion remains subjective. As Rolex enthusiasts continue to weigh in, the community’s evolving language will undoubtedly shape the future of these iconic timepieces.